Files and links (1)
Published (Version of record)CC BY-NC-ND V4.0, Open
Journal article
The Certainty of the Evidence on Plant-vs Meat-Predominant Dietary Patterns and Depression: An Umbrella Review
Nutrition Reviews, Vol.First online, pp.1-14
18/06/2025
Appears in Recent Faculty of Education Publications
Metrics
1 Record Views
Abstract
Context: Diets rich in plant foods are associated with reduced risk of depressive symptoms. However, previous studies have reported greater depressive symptomology in patients who follow a plant-predominant dietary pattern. Meta-analyses and systematic reviews of associations of plant-and meat-predominant diets and depression have highlighted conflicting results.
Objectives: In this umbrella review we applied A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews 2 (AMSTAR2) to explore the state of evidence regarding possible associations of plant-and meat-predominant dietary patterns with depression.
Data Sources: Six databases were searched from the date of inception to January 2025: CINAHL, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Scopus, and Web of Science.
Data Extraction: Data were extracted by 2 independent researchers using Covidence software.
Data Analysis: The search revealed 104 studies, of which 9 met inclusion criteria. Data were synthesized and narratively grouped by plant-predominant and meat-predominant dietary patterns.
Conclusions: Five articles reported associations between plant-and meat-predominant dietary patterns and depression, 4 reported that plant-predominant dietary patterns increased depression, and 5 found conflicting or no associations. Similar systematic search terms, overlap of primary studies, and short timeframes between reviews raise concerns about the validity and scientific contribution of repeated systematic review of this topic. To address these concerns, we highlight the need for greater awareness of methodological issues, including high reliance on observational studies, high levels of heterogeneity, imprecision of measurement tools, and lack of measurement of dietary adherence and composition.
Details
- Title
- The Certainty of the Evidence on Plant-vs Meat-Predominant Dietary Patterns and Depression: An Umbrella Review
- Creators
- Megan F Lee - Bond UniversityJessica Bayes - Southern Cross UniversityAhmed A. Moustafa - Bond UniversityMaximilian A. Storz - University of FreiburgTalitha Best - Central Queensland University
- Publication Details
- Nutrition Reviews, Vol.First online, pp.1-14
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press; CARY
- Grant note
- Bond University librarians with developing and tailoring of the search string for this study
We acknowledge the assistance of the Bond University librarians with developing and tailoring of the search string for this study.
- Identifiers
- 991013291352802368
- Copyright
- © The Author(s) 2025.
- Academic Unit
- Faculty of Education; National Centre for Naturopathic Medicine
- Language
- English
- Resource Type
- Journal article